The Hightoppers and the Rollmeisters had been competing in the City Bowling League for a long time. While the Hightoppers would be eligible for the Senior League. They had been together so long and enjoyed the competition, but they stayed with the City League. The Rollmeisters had a couple of the original members, but most of the team had been around for three or four years. They were very different teams, and that difference was most telling when one of their bowlers got in a slump.
The two teams met in the championship tournament at the end of the season. They were evenly matched. Each had a solid lead-off roller who was part of the original team. The middle guys were steady handicap bowlers who could be counted on to meet or beat their average. The most significant difference was in their closer.
The Hightoppers' closer was one of the original members. He was consistent and could usually bring the three strikes when they needed them. The Rollmeisters' closer had been on the team for a year. He had come on the team at the beginning of the season after the closer from last year's team quit when the team blamed him for losing the championship game. This year's closer had a high average and a reputation as a stiff competitor.
The three-game series was coming to an end. The teams had split the first two games and were only a few pins apart, with the Hightoppers holding a very narrow advantage. It looked like it was all going to come down to the last bowler in the last frame.
The Hightoppers' last man, Billy, was feeling the pressure. The rest of the team could see that he was sweating out the last frame. All he needed was three strikes for the win. But he struggled throughout the last game. The rest of the team made up for his slump, but he knew he was on his own now. As always, the team reminded him that they were here to enjoy the game. They played their best and competed hard, but at night's end, they wanted to look back and say they had a good time. They joked and did their best to keep Billy loose. He rolled a spare with a nine-pin count. The team congratulated and surrounded him on the approach with handshakes and back-slapping.
The Rollmeisters' last man, Charlie, knew that all he had to do was two strikes and a decent count to win the series. Every team member had also calculated possible scoring and reminded Charlie as he stepped on the approach. Charlie was sweating. The Team Captain, the spirit of the team, said, "Ok, Charlie, this is why we let you on the team last year. Don't let us down!" Charlie's anxiety jumped. He rolled his first ball, and it was a little light in the pocket but enough to carry all the pins. As he walked back, the team captain looked Charlie in the eye and said, "Ok, you got lucky on that one. But it won't mean a thing if you don't bury the next one in the pocket!"
Charlie turned and picked up his ball, and started his delivery routine. His mind was shouting, "Don't screw up!" But muscle memory took over, and he delivered a perfect strike sweeping every pin off the lane. The rest of the team cheered, but the Captain stood stone-faced and held up 6 fingers, saying, "Don't blow it now. All you need is six."
Charlie could barely hear anyone except for the Captain. As he made his approach, he felt the sweat running down his back. As soon as he let go of the ball, he knew something was wrong. The ball tracked too heavy and hit high in the pocket. When all the pins had settled, he had a split, but he got his six pins. Everyone on the team applauded, knowing they had won the series. The Captain said, "Good thing you are lucky, or else you would have been looking for a new team next year." He then turned and walked away.
Meanwhile, the Hightoppers were walking over to congratulate the Rollmeisters. The conversation then turned to talk about where to go and celebrate the series. Billy and the whole team were grateful that they loved the game (and one another) too much to suck the joy out with a desperate need to win. They had too much respect for each other to ever treat one of their teammates the way Charlie had been treated by his team captain.
One team believed that a missed shot was the bowler's fault and that he alone could and should fix it. Their usual response was blaming and criticizing. If the bowler could not deliver, then he was replaceable.
The other team loved their teammates more than they loved winning another trophy. They looked at a slump by one player as a problem that should and could be addressed only as a team. Their standard response was to do their best to make up the difference while offering encouragement to their slumping member. If the struggling bowler does their best and respects the team with their effort, then he is irreplaceable. He was part of the team and was treated as such, no matter how good a night he might have.
Suppose you find yourself in a community (a club, a church, a sports team, or a workplace) that sees you as replaceable even when you have done your best. In that case, consider a change.
If winning is more important than belonging, you may need teams. If others are quick to criticize and slow to acknowledge and respect who you are, you may need some new associates. If being a part of the group depends upon your being who the group wants you to be, this is a toxic group, and it is time to admit that this place is unhealthy. Look for a "Hightoppers" to join. And allow the love you find among them to give you the resilience you need to enjoy life in that community.